Without Consent: A Landmark Trial and the Decades-Long Struggle to Make Spousal Rape a Crime by Sarah Weinman
TW: sexual assault, domestic violence, and abuse.
It wasn't until 1978 that a wife accused her husband of rape in a courtroom in the United States. Greta Rideout had endured physical and sexual violence from her husband, John Rideout. Sometimes she stopped fighting him because of his threats to their young daughter. But after meeting with a counselor, she contextualized part of his abuse as rape--a crime she hadn't previously conceived a husband could commit against his wife.
But despite Greta's testimony, John was acquitted. And, instead, it was Greta the media and public found guilty with one escalation leading to someone attacking her. It would be much longer after the trial that it would be legally determined a spouse could have raped their spouse. It was not until 1993 that marital rape was a crime in every state. Yet, even today, some states have exceptions or narrow definitions regarding the crime. This was a horrifying realization I had while reading Without Consent: A Landmark Trial and the Decades-Long Struggle to Make Spousal Rape a Crime by Sarah Weinman.
Weinman deftly (yet with kind sympathy for the survivors) lays out the trial of John Rideout, as well as the aftermath for both Greta and John. John, tragically, but not surprisingly, went on to assault more women (he was ultimately convicted of raping two different women whom he hadn't married in 2017). She also traces other landmark cases and laws that led to marital rape finally being recognized nationwide as a crime. This larger history she shares while being considerate about how into the legal nitty gritty she was diving. Often, histories (particularly legal ones) can be presented with confusing jargon, minutiae that confuses rather than enlightens, and expectations that readers have instantly memorized every point and date.
I do want to note that while Weinman does delve into details of the assaults, my experience as a reader was that she was doing so to demonstrate the violence of the crimes and the lasting trauma the assaults left on survivors. I share this because there are times when I have encountered authors or journalists who seem to be sharing such details to sensationalize or even titillate their audience (or, worse, themselves). However, if hearing such details would be upsetting for you, I do want to warn you that they are present in this book and are painful to encounter.
Without Consent: A Landmark Trial and the Decades-Long Struggle to Make Spousal Rape a Crime by Sarah Weinman introduced me to vital history by a considerate expert. I was never taught this violent legal history, and I had naively thought that the law would not have, so recently, suggested marriage meant permanent, irrevocable, and all encompassing consent. I encourage you to learn more about this topic whether it is from Weinman's expert book or through a broader overview.
Without Consent: A Landmark Trial and the Decades-Long Struggle to Make Spousal Rape a Crime by Sarah Weinman, Ecco


Comments
Post a Comment